It’s been a month and change since I last posted a mortgage match-up, so without further ado, here’s the latest installment.
There are likely thousands of articles that deal with this subject, all with plenty of differing opinions, but we are in unprecedented times.
Mortgage rates have never been lower than they’ve been over the past year, and that changes the argument quite a bit.
Can You Earn a Better Return Than Your Mortgage Rate?
As I noted in a recent post, the 30-year fixed averaged 5.72% over the past decade, and 6.52% over the past 20 years. The average jumps to 7.45% over the past 30 years.
For those who opted to take out a 15-year fixed, interest rates are in the high 2% range.
Clearly this is material enough to make borrowers think twice about what to do with their money.
Do you pay your mortgage off early, on schedule, or go with something even more extreme like an interest-only loan?
In the past, it may have been ambitious to think you could earn a better return than your 5-7% mortgage rate, but now that rates are in the 3% range, it sounds a lot more practical.
If you factor in the mortgage interest deduction (assuming you itemize), your effective mortgage rate is even lower.
Of course, there are taxes on investment gains as well, so it’s somewhat awash.
Savings Rates Are Terrible
Assuming you think you can beat your mortgage rate, the first place one might look is a savings account.
After all, they’re a relatively safe place to put your money with little risk aside from your bank going under and not having FDIC insurance.
Unfortunately, savings accounts are yielding next to nothing these days. In fact, most yield less than 1% at the moment.
So if you chose to simply invest in one of these accounts, rather than pay down your mortgage, you’d be losing out by carrying mortgage debt, even at a low rate of 3.625%.
However, the interest rate on your 30-year fixed mortgage will never change, whereas savings account yields will probably rise over time.
But until they do, stashing away money that pays you a 1% return while holding more expensive debt isn’t necessarily the wisest decision.
Factor in inflation, and it’s even more a losing proposition, assuming your money can’t even keep up.
Of course, most homeowners need to set aside some amount of cash in an emergency fund or whatever you want to call it just in case something goes wrong.
So putting it someplace where it will grow, albeit slowly, without major downside risk, is prudent.
What About Mutual Funds and Stocks?
For the more confident investor, a better place to put your money could be in mutual funds or stocks.
Or perhaps a dividend-paying stock that yields more than your existing mortgage rate.
Just look at a blue chip like AT&T (NYSE:T) currently yielding 4.88%. Sure, the stock price can go down, but if the stock goes up and you get that yield (or close to it), it could be a winning move for your money.
But beware that when you choose to invest in one of these financial instruments, the risk goes up. As a rule of thumb, the more you stand to gain, the more you could lose. It’s a risk/reward thing.
Still, with mortgage rates as low as they are, you don’t need to be Warren Buffett to win the game.
However, there is a ton of risk in the stock market. As we saw during the financial crisis, plenty of seemingly too-big-to-fail companies went down, such as Bear Stearns, Countrywide, Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, Wachovia, Washington Mutual, and so on.
I’m sure plenty of investors held these companies in their portfolios, and few imagined ever losing their entire stake. Could it happen again? Sure it could.
So how did those who paid down their mortgage make out compared to those who were highly leveraged in the stock market?
Well, they probably kept their mortgage balances above water, meaning they’ve got some home equity, but there’s a good chance many are still trapped in their homes.
In other words, they may have purchased a home or refinanced during the height of the market, and are now paying down an oversized mortgage.
So it’s important to remember that your home can lose value as well – it’s not a foregone conclusion that you’ll make money in real estate.
There’s No Easy Answer
When it comes down to it, it’s not a simple or straightforward question.
There are so many variables that you really need to whip out a calculator, talk to your CPA, visit a financial planner and/or retirement specialist, and so on and so forth.
Does your employer provide a 401k match? Is your money better off in another type of retirement account? Do you have other high-APR debt? How much do you need to set aside for a rainy day?
I will say that mortgages have a lot of desirable qualities that make them the best debt to carry.
Very few loans come with extremely low fixed interest rates that are tax deductible and amortized over a long period of time.
So if there was ever a loan to hold onto, a mortgage would be it, especially with rates where they’re at now.
If we assume inflation picks up in coming years, your existing mortgage becomes even more attractive to hang onto, as opposed to paying down, seeing that the debt will be paid back in cheaper dollars from the future.
If rates happen to go down, you have the option to refinance to a lower rate, which also provides flexibility.
And if you invest money early on instead of paying down your mortgage, your gains can be exponentially better.
Finally, there’s also the emotional element. Some folks like the idea of being debt-free, for better or worse, financially.
Not everyone likes to invest in complicated securities or even seemingly benign blue chip stocks, so their goal might be to eliminate the debt overhang as quickly as possible.
In either case, it’s always smart to set aside some readily accessible funds in the case of an emergency, or even to replace your roof or handle some other household repairs.
The key is really finding a balance. There’s no rule for how much you need to pay other than your payment due. You can make an extra payment here and there or look into biweekly mortgage payments, or just pay on schedule and spread your money around as needed/desired.
Pros of Paying Off the Mortgage
- Pay less interest
- Own your home free and clear faster
- Get rid of mortgage insurance
- Gain more home equity
- If rates fall and you refinance, lower LTV = lower interest rate
- You can sell your home more easily
- Less risk of losing money in the stock market or elsewhere
- Less work
- No debt at retirement
- Peace of mind
Pros of Investing Instead
- Mortgage rates will never be this low again
- Long-term low fixed rate a great deal
- Mortgage interest deductible
- Money remains liquid
- Investment gains can exceed return on mortgage
- Investing early can make for greater long-term returns
- Ability to diversify your investments
- Contributions to retirement account may be more beneficial
- Inflation makes mortgage balance cheaper in the future
- Home could lose value
- Avoid throwing good money after bad if underwater on your mortgage
Read more: How to pay off your mortgage faster.